Book Club of the Heavyweights

Booknotes looks at the relationship between Nathaniel Hawthorne and Herman Melville

Nathaniel Hawthorne (left) and Herman Melville.

Nathaniel Hawthorne (left) and Herman Melville.

Mike Selby

On August 5, 1850, a freak lightning storm struck Monument Mountain (Great Barrington, Mass.), forcing a group of hikers into a cave for safety. The small group was a book club, and they had set out on their hike for literary reasons.

A century before, a Mohican woman had thrown herself off of the summit, after being forbidden to marry the man she loved (unfortunately for her he was her cousin). When her body was found, members of her tribe covered her in rocks, simultaneously creating a monument to the tragedy and a name of the mountain.

Poet William Cullen Bryant had immortalized the story in his poem ‘Monument Mountain,’ writing “There is a tale about these reverend rocks / A sad tradition of unhappy love / And sorrows borne and ended, long ago.”

Inspired by Bryant’s poem, the book club members had come to retrace the woman’s steps up the mountain.  The plan was to reach the summit, and toast the Mohican woman with the champagne they had brought.

Forced into the cave by the storm, the book club members got to know each other a bit better, as they had never met until that morning. Instead of attending regular meetings, this group discussed books through the mail. Another odd characteristic of was that each member rarely discussed books each of them had read. They only discussed books they had written.

Nathaniel Hawthorne, Herman Melville, and Oliver Wendell Holmes had begun corresponding with each other at the suggestion of David Dudley, a lawyer known to all three.  Dudley had invited all three to meet each other on the August 5 hike.

Holmes was a Boston physician, poet, novelist, and medical reformer. The first physician to use a stethoscope in the U.S., he is best remembered for his books ‘The Autocrat at the Breakfast Table,’ and ‘Elsie Venner’ — the first of what would later become known as the medical thriller genre.

Hawthorne was a highly successful short story writer and novelist, most famous for ‘The House of the Seven Gables,’ and ‘The Scarlet Letter.’

Melville was the odd man out. He was decades younger than these two great men of American letters, and had not yet found writing success. His first novel, ‘Typee,’ was one of those much talked about but seldom read books, and he was having difficulty getting any other work published.

What Holmes said in the cave remains unknown, but the usually reserved Melville unburdened all that was in heart to Hawthorne.  Hawthorne in turn offered the young man encouragement, and to not give up.

After this momentous hike (which they did complete after the storm abated), Melville moved his wife and children across the state into a house next door to Hawthorne’s. Hawthorne’s words of inspiration in the mountain cave had meant everything to Melville, who was finally able to begin and finish his own monument —’Moby Dick.’

The first page of ‘Moby Dick’ even opens with: “To Nathaniel Hawthorne: In token of my admiration for his genius.”

And if only the story ended there. Although neighbours, the two men continued to write constantly to each other.  These letters have been pure gold to literary biographers, critics, students and fans of each or both writers.

What was always noticed but never quite admitted to until recently is that Melville’s letters appear gay.

Passages such as “Whence come you, Hawthorne? By what right do you drink from my flagon of life? And when I put it to my lips — lo, they are yours and not mine,” and “[Hawthorne put] his strong New England roots in the hot soil of my Southern soul,” have fuelled much speculation over the years.

Speculation is the key word here, as the letters are all that remains. There is no evidence of a relationship between the two men, and only Melville’s letters have the hint of homoeroticism to them.

While Holmes and Hawthorne died as celebrated authors, Melville sadly did not. ‘Moby Dick’ was seen as a disaster when it first appeared, and the publisher had to destroy thousands of unsold copies. Melville died destitute, lonely, and forgotten.  It wasn’t until the generation after his that the book was seen to be one of genius.

One that wouldn’t have been written if he hadn’t poured his heart out to Hawthorne that day in the cave.

Mike Selby is Reference Librarian at the Cranbrook Public Library

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A man wearing a face mask to prevent the spread of COVID-19 walks past a mural in Vancouver on Monday, Nov. 30, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Marissa Tiel
212 new COVID-19 cases in Interior Health over the weekend

A total of 490 cases remain active; 15 in hospital

Incumbent MLA Tom Shypitka is contesting Kootenay East for the BC Liberals. (Scott Tibballs / The Free Press)
Shypitka named opposition critic for Energy, Mines and Low Carbon Innovation

The Kootenay East MLA has held the energy and mines portfolio since 2017

Item no 22, De-Kieviet Kindergarten class - Highlands, Starting Bid: $20
Christmas Village 2020 school auction items

The annual Christmas Village has gone virtual, here are the auction items from local schools

File Photo
Missing hunter found dead in South Country

A hunter was reported as overdue on Nov. 29, and was found deceased on Nov. 30 following an RCMP and SAR operation

(Black Press file photo)
RCMP seeking driver of burnt out car found on HaHa Creek Road

Cranbrook RCMP are looking for the driver of a vehicle that was found on fire Monday

The bids for the 2020 Christmas Village are open as of noon on Thursday, November 26. Please scroll through this album to see auction items available for bidding.
Christmas Village 2020 auction items

The Christmas Village has gone virtual, here are all the details

Fossil finds at Mt. Stephen. (Photo: Sarah Fuller/Parks Canada)
Extreme hiking, time travel and science converge in the Burgess Shale

Climb high in the alpine and trace your family tree back millions of years – to our ocean ancestors

Kettle bells sit aligned in an indoor fitness studio. (
1 COVID-19 case at a B.C. fitness studio leads to 104 more infections, 6 school exposures

According to case data released by Fraser Health, one case of the novel coronavirus carries a big impact

Vehicles drive past a display thanking essential workers in Burnaby, B.C. on Sunday, Nov. 29, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Marissa Tiel
B.C. changing COVID-19 case reporting as virus spread continues

Manual counting takes more time, leads to errors

Black Press Media and BraveFace have come together to support children facing life-threatening conditions. Net proceeds from these washable, reusable, three-layer masks go to Make-A-Wish Foundation BC & Yukon.
Put on a BraveFace: Mask fundraiser helps make children’s wishes come true

From Black Press Media + BraveFace – adult, youth and kid masks support Make-A-Wish Foundation

Christy Jordan-Fenton is the co-author of the book Fatty Legs, which has been mentioned amid the controversy of an Abbotsford school assignment on residential schools.
Co-author of residential schools book condemns controversial Abbotsford class assignment

Children’s book mentioned amid controversy at W. A. Fraser Middle School

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good
Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

Kootenay East MLA Tom Shypitka takes over as energy and mines critic for the B.C. Liberal opposition. Kelowna-Lake Country MLA Norm Letnick (right) moves from health critic to assistant deputy speaker. (Hansard TV)
B.C. Liberals pick critics to take on Horgan’s NDP majority

Interim leader Shirley Bond takes seniors, long-term care

Most Read