A lesson from Switzerland

A salary cap for CEOs? Not a bad idea. Would any North American government try it?

Get out the red paint and colour me a socialist, because I’m about to decry wage inequality.

Later this month, Switzerland voters will have their say in a referendum calling for a cap on CEO salaries to 12 times the salary of the company’s lowest paid staff member.

While this proposal may or may not pass, the fact is that Switzerland already has far greater wage equality than Canada and the U.S.

At the moment, Swiss CEOs earn about 43 times the average worker.

Meanwhile in Canada, studies show that in 2011, our top 100 CEOs earned 175 times more than the average Canadian.

Put another way, by 1:18 p.m. on January 2, Canada’s top 100 CEOs will have already pocketed $45,448. It takes the average Canadian an entire year of full-time work to earn that.

Inequality is the steepest in Calgary, where the richest one per cent earn 26 times the average Canadian worker. In Vancouver, that figure is 15 times the average, while in Halifax and Ottawa it is 11 times the average.

Resource, pharmaceutical and technology companies paid their CEOs the most in 2011. The year’s largest earner was Frank Stronach, former CEO of Magna, which makes technologically advanced automotive systems. With a base salary of $68,000, Stronach earned a $38 million bonus that year.

Bradley Shaw of Shaw Communications earned $15.8 million in 2011, placing him at number four.

The Bank of Montreal and TD Bank paid their CEOs $11.4 million, while RBC paid theirs $11.2 million.

Don Lindsay, Teck Resource’s CEO was number 22 on the list, earning a base salary of $1.3 million, a bonus of $1.4 million, shares of $2.9 million, options of $2.9 million and a pension of $495,000, totalling $9.3 million.

These statistics are courtesy of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.

Yet compared to other Western economies, Canada is about average, according to the Gini Index. Worse than us is Japan, Australia and the U.K, but we are less equal than Spain, Germany, Austria and Sweden.

Wage inequality in the U.S. is close to the worst. CEOs earned 231 times the typical worker in 2011. In the restaurant industry alone, the average pay for a restaurant CEO is $11.8 million, a staggering 788 times what a worker on minimum wage would earn working full time in a year.

Putting Switzerland’s proposal aside, what can Canada do about wage inequality? Many say that if CEOs were being paid more than they are worth, shareholders and the directors of the board wouldn’t stand for it.

But if the governance of one company lowered its CEO’s salary, they would simply find it impossible to fill the position. It would need to be an equal drop in all of the country’s top-paying positions.

Taxation, of course, goes a long way to remediate the inequality across the board.

Researchers at the Ottawa-based Centre for the Study of Living Standards found that between 1981 and 2010, before-tax income rose 19.4 per cent. But government taxation and benefits meant that income inequality rose 13.5 per cent during that period. That means that income inequality was 44 per cent less severe than it would have been had government not intervened.

This all goes to indicate that a salary cap for CEOs is a pretty good idea (thanks very much, Switzerland). Yet no North American government would try it, because it would be hugely unpopular among the people who fund political campaigns. And there’s the rub.

There seems to be no way around it. And that’s very grim.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Kimberley/Cranbrook entertainment listings

Pictured above: The cast of Cranbrook Community Theatre’s “The Fighting Days,” which… Continue reading

Cranbrook Bucks sign first player to team

The Key City’s newest hockey franchise has begun to take shape as… Continue reading

Columbia Valley RCMP searching for missing Invermere woman

Police believe Belinda Eugene may be hitch hiking to the Kamloops area

Final preparations, practicing at WFP ahead of BC Curling Championships

Western Financial Place was a hive of activity on Monday, Jan. 27… Continue reading

Health Foundation hits $1 million mark of $1.2 million fundraiser

The East Kootenay Foundation for Health has $200K more to go to purchase SPECT CT machine

B.C. reports first coronavirus in Vancouver region

First patient visited Wuhan, China, reported symptoms

‘Very disrespectful’: Headstones at Okanagan cemetery damaged by excavation crew

Headstones at Enderby’s Cliffside Cemetery mistakenly driven over by excavation crew

Despite reports of decline, birds flocking to national parks in Canadian Rockies

Recent studies suggest overall bird population has slid by three billion since 1970

Former UN committee member defends stance on B.C.’s Coastal GasLink pipeline

First Nations LNG Alliance accused UN committee, human rights watchdog of not doing their research

Opioid crisis to blame for shorter life expectancy in B.C. men, says Stats Can

Opioid crisis held responsible for declining life expectancy

Earthquake on top of highway closure a wake up call for Island’s West Coast

“When someone says, ‘Be prepared for 72 hours,’ that means exactly that: be prepared.”

Pregnant B.C. woman stuck in Wuhan, the epicentre of coronavirus outbreak

Woman is due to give birth in Wuhan, China unless she can get out

Taxi association asks B.C. Supreme Court to stop Uber, Lyft from operating

Petition alleges Passenger Transportation Board did not take taxis into account

Most Read