Polygamy trial wraps up

Crown rebuts defence closing arguments, decision likely reserved for a few months

Jim Oler (front left) and Winston Blackmore (right) are currently facing a polygamy charge and are standing trial in Cranbrook Supreme Court.

The trial of two fundamentalist Mormons charged with polygamy wrapped up in Cranbrook Supreme Court as crown counsel argued the bulk of various marriage and personal records entered as evidence corroborated each other.

Peter Wilson, a special prosecutor serving as crown counsel, hit back against suggestions from the defence that the records were unreliable during closing arguments in the trial of Winston Blackmore and Jim Oler, two polygamist leaders associated with Bountiful in southeastern B.C.

Blackmore’s polygamy indictment lists 24 alleged marriages between 1990 and 2014, while Oler was charged with the same offence between five women between 1993 and 2009.

Following Wilson’s rebuttal to defence closing arguments on Thursday, Justice Sheri Donegan agreed to fix a date next week to schedule the delivery of her ruling in a few months.

Wilson’s rebuttal from Blair Suffredine, Blackmore’s lawyer, centred on suggestions that the records were unreliable and that the crown and to prove the accused had both a marriage and conjugal relationship with multiple women over two dozen years.

The records, which were seized by law enforcement at a fundamentalist Mormon compound in Texas in 2008, included marriage and personal records for members spanning the U.S. and into Canada.

While Suffredine argued the unreliability of the evidence contained within the records, some of which were incomplete, Wilson responded that the documentary information as a whole contain corroborating evidence that fill in gaps from individual marriage and personal records.

Wilson also argued that the Crown does not have to prove the polygamous marriages were a continuous relationship, as suggested by Suffredine and Joe Doyle, a court-appointed lawyer who is there to ensure a fair trial because Oler is self-represented.

Wilson pointed to a constitutional reference case in 2011 that defined polygamy as a crime and that the harms outweigh the individual rights to freedom of religion.

Part of that ruling concluded the crown does not have to prove that the relationships were ongoing or whether they lasted or not, just that a marriage or a conjugal union had occurred, Wilson said.

Crown does not have to prove each alleged wife was in a polygamous relationship, Wilson argued, bringing up case law from perjury charges stemming from both the Air India bombing and the tasering death of Robert Dziekanski at the Vancouver International Airport.

In both cases, a single person was charged with one count of perjury, in spite of making multiple incriminating statements, which is a similar situation to Blackmore and Oler being charged with only one count of polygamy for having many wives, Wilson said.

Just Posted

La Niña sending us a cold, snowy winter

Current warm weather coming from southeast of Hawaii, but that’s going to change

Cranbrook gets new, much-needed psychologist

Dr. Thompson is now the only registered psychologist in the entire East Kootenay

Cranbrook snow plow operator helps save elderly man

The 73-year-old man had fallen at his isolated home, and finally was able to call for help

Trouble at the drive-thru

Customer freaks out after finding order not complete

Townhouse development will be going ahead on 4th Street South

The proposal to build a townhouse-style development on 4th Street South, near… Continue reading

Local climbers need support

A fundraiser at Arq Mountain Centre on Dec. 8 will help three climbers get to World Cup Tour

Local climbers need support

A fundraiser at Arq Mountain Centre on Dec. 8 will help three climbers get to World Cup Tour

Trouble from the double-booking? You ain’t seen nothing yet

Wild Theatre’s ‘The Lodge’ opens at the Key City Theatre tonight, Thursday, Nov. 23

An adopted cat is the best 10 pounds you’ll gain this season

BC SPCA encouraging families to add a forever feline friend during adoption event Nov. 24 to Dec. 3

Uber official says public needs to push for ridesharing in B.C.

Mike van Hemmen tells Kelowna Chamber of commerce ridesharing would be ‘win-win-win’

B.C. co-ops relieved with Ottawa’s housing strategy

Federal government to have a new co-operative housing funding model in place by 2020

B.C. NDP referendum plan sparks legislature battle

David Eby says public will decide on proportional referendum

Hammy has been freed of his threads, a purple antler remains

The iconic Prince Rupert buck with a piece of hammock attached to his antlers was caught by COs

Court adjourned again for man linked to Shuswap farm where human remains found

Curtis Sagmoen will appear back in court on Dec. 14

Most Read